When Your Ex Stops Working or Says They Earn Nothing: How a Reason 8 Change of Assessment Works

Woman seated at a wooden table using a silver laptop, with a backpack and a wide-brim blue hat resting on a chair nearby in a bright, homey space on a sunny day.

The short version

  • A standard child support assessment runs mainly on each parent’s adjusted taxable income: the figure from the tax return, plus a few add-backs. If that figure no longer reflects the reality of your situation, the assessment may become unfair.
  • ‘Reason 8’ is the name Services Australia gives to one of ten grounds for asking for a change. It covers an assessment that is unfair because of a parent’s income, property, financial resources or earning capacity.
  • It works both ways. You can apply if you’re paying and your ex has voluntarily reduced their working hours, or if you’re receiving payments and your ex’s reported income doesn’t reflect their lifestyle. Services Australia can also start a change itself.
  • It is a high bar, and the earning capacity part has three tests that must all be met. Nobody can promise how an application will go.

Child support looks simple from a distance. Each parent’s income goes in, the formula runs and a number comes out.

Where things falter is on the exact interpretation of the word income. The formula leans on what each parent reports to the tax office, not on what they could earn or what they actually have. For most families, that is close enough. For others, it isn’t, and the difference can have a significant impact over the years during which a family pays or receives child support.

This article looks at that gap from both sides of the table, through two invented examples. Neither is a real family, and nothing in them comes from a real matter.

How the assessment sees income

A standard assessment is built on each parent’s adjusted taxable income: broadly, this means taxable income plus a few other amounts, such as reportable fringe benefits. The formula then compares each parent’s share of the combined income with each parent’s share of the costs of the children, which is worked out from how much care each provides.

Two things follow. The formula doesn’t ask what you could earn. And it doesn’t count savings, property or money sitting in a company or trust unless that money shows up as taxable income. That is deliberate. It keeps the system fast and predictable for the majority of families.

When the result is clearly unfair because of one of ten specific grounds, there is a second pathway. This is known as a change of assessment in special circumstances.

What ‘Reason 8’ actually is

Services Australia lists ten reasons for a change. Reason 8 is the one that concerns money. That’s to say, the assessment is unfair because of the income, earning capacity, property or financial resources of one or both parents. The Act has no ‘Reason 8’ label of its own. The wording lives in section 117(2)(c) of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, which the Registrar applies through section 98C. 

The Department of Social Services’ guide for decision-makers splits it into two:

  • 8A: income, property and financial resources that aren’t properly reflected in the assessment.
  • 8B: earning capacity, where a parent could earn more than the assessment shows.

Either way, the decision-maker works through the same three steps.

  1. Is there a ground in ‘special circumstances’? The Act doesn’t define the phrase. The guide quotes the Family Court describing it as something special or out of the ordinary.
  2. Does the standard assessment produce an unjust and inequitable result because of that ground?
  3. Would a change be just and equitable for the child and both parents, and otherwise proper?

Being unhappy with the amount isn’t grounds for an application, and Services Australia makes this clear in its guidance. Many applications start because a parent is paying more than expected, but that alone isn’t sufficient grounds.

Either parent can apply, and so can a non-parent carer. Services Australia can also start a change on its own initiative.

Scenario one: ‘My ex decided to take a year off’

This example is invented.

Let’s imagine a situation where two parents separated several years ago. One of them pays child support. The other has the children most nights and has worked full-time throughout. After the property settlement, the second parent sells a home, moves into a rental and resigns, saying they need eighteen months to reset. Their reported income falls to nothing.

Nothing about the paying parent’s life has changed. Their assessment jumps, because their share of the combined income has jumped. They didn’t choose this situation, and they feel its financial impact every week.

The other parent sees it differently. They have worked for twenty years, the children are well looked after, and they think a break is a reasonable thing to want.

Both positions are understandable. Here is what the law actually asks, though.

The formula uses what was reported. If the resigned parent reports no income, that is the figure the standard assessment uses. The formula doesn’t ask why.

The paying parent can apply under the earning capacity limb. Under section 117(7B), the decision-maker can treat a parent’s earning capacity as higher than their actual income only if all three of these hold:

  1. The parent isn’t working despite having plenty of opportunities, has reduced their hours below what’s considered full-time in their occupation, or has changed their occupation, industry or working pattern.
  2. The parent’s decision isn’t justified by their caring responsibilities or health circumstances.
  3. The parent hasn’t shown that changing the child support assessment wasn’t one of the main reasons for their decision.

Let’s start with the third test, which may surprise some parents. The burden is on the parent who stopped working.

The law starts with what’s known as a rebuttable presumption. This means it’s initially assumed that one of the parent’s main reasons for stopping work was to affect their child support assessment. The parent must then show that this wasn’t the case by explaining what actually motivated their decision.

Importantly, the law refers to ‘a major purpose’, not ‘the major purpose’. In other words, affecting child support doesn’t have to be the main reason for the decision. It only needs to have been one of the most important factors the parent considered at the time.

The second test is judged objectively. The question is whether an ordinary, reasonable person would think the caring or health reason justified the decision, not whether the parent who made it thinks so. 

Caring responsibilities can include people other than the children. For a parent who has long been the main carer, the guide recognises that a longstanding arrangement may mean no extra earning capacity at all. Health is usually backed by medical evidence from a treating doctor.

The decision-maker must also be satisfied that the parent could realistically earn more. This means suitable work must be available in their area, and they must have the qualifications needed to do it.

So is a voluntary break ‘tough luck’ for the paying parent? Not necessarily, but the opposite isn’t automatically true either. The guide says the earning capacity policy is meant to leave room for life decisions such as a career change. It isn’t meant to second-guess every choice about work. But a decision to stop with no caring or health reason, made by someone who could readily find work, doesn’t get an automatic pass. Which way it falls turns on the evidence about why the decision was made.

What about the money from the house sale? That sits on the other limb. Sale proceeds aren’t income. But under section 117(7A)(a), the decision-maker must consider a parent’s capacity to generate income, including from assets that aren’t currently producing income but could. It isn’t enough to say money is tied up or earning too little to be of importance. The Registrar can look at a parent’s resources as a whole, including their ability to restructure their affairs or borrow against assets. How a property settlement has affected a parent’s assets is also part of the picture.

What tends to matter, going by the guide’s own lists:

  • For the paying parent: payslips and job history, evidence that work was offered or is available, anything showing why the other parent stopped, and a clear picture of what the resigning parent now holds.
  • For the parent who stopped: what you were weighing when you decided, what you are living on, how you’ve thought about supporting the children, and medical evidence if health is part of it. For study, the course, its length and the prospect of work afterwards.

It’s worth remembering that no Reason 8 application is guaranteed to succeed. Neither quitting a job nor demanding that someone return to work is a good idea if you’re simply assuming the outcome will be in your favour.

Also read: Co-Parenting Red Flags: How Australian Family Courts Rate Your Behaviour

Scenario two: ‘I earn nothing’

This example is invented.

Let’s flip the previous scenario on its head. A parent who receives child support learns that the other parent reports an income of a few thousand dollars a year. Yet that parent drives a late-model car, takes holidays and has recently renovated. The receiving parent suspects cash work, or income running through a family business that sends money to relatives.

The Registrar can look beyond the tax return. The Department of Social Services’ guide is explicit that the Registrar can add income and resources that never formed part of adjusted taxable income. If income has been taxed at a low rate or hasn’t been taxed at all, it can be adjusted upwards to make it comparable with other income.

The guide lists what the Registrar looks at, and it reads like a checklist of the questions this scenario raises:

  • Whether the parent has been able to maintain a lifestyle and acquire assets their reported income couldn’t fund.
  • Whether the parent has benefits from a business that don’t appear as income.
  • Whether a business has been structured to reduce the parent’s income, how much control the parent has over it, and whether income is being split.
  • Who actually does the work.

Scrutiny falls on companies, trusts and partnerships. If a parent earns income through personal effort but it’s paid to a company, trust or partnership, the guide calls that alienation of income. For a trust, the Registrar can look at the trust deed, who the settlor, trustee and beneficiaries are, whether any trust income has been applied for the parent’s benefit, and whether the parent really controls the assets and income. Retained profits in a company, or undistributed profits in a trust where the parent is a beneficiary or trustee, can also be considered.

Money paid to relatives can be treated as the parent’s own. If a parent’s business pays wages to a new partner or family member, and the payments exceed the reasonable value of the work performed, the guide says the Registrar can treat that income as the parent’s.

But a relative’s income doesn’t count by default. Under section 117(7A)(b)(i), the decision-maker must disregard the income and resources of someone who has no duty to maintain the child, unless special circumstances make it appropriate to consider them. A new partner’s wage, or an uncle’s savings, isn’t the parent’s income just because they live under the same roof or share a family.

Cash work is particularly difficult to prove. Income that doesn’t appear on a tax return won’t be reflected in the standard assessment. Although the law allows the decision-maker to look beyond the tax return, establishing how much someone actually earns can be challenging.

The Registrar, not the applicant, has the formal powers. Under section 161, the Registrar can require a person, by written notice, to give information, attend and answer questions, or produce documents. The notice must allow at least seven days, and failing to comply without a reasonable excuse is an offence carrying up to six months’ imprisonment. It is a reasonable excuse if complying might tend to incriminate the person. The Registrar can also decide the issues are too complex to deal with in this process and refuse to make a determination (section 98E). The Act separately lets a court make departure orders on the same grounds.

Suspicion versus evidence. A single photo of a glamorous holiday isn’t evidence of income. A pattern is more useful: a business name or ABN, advertising for services, a trail of payments, assets that appear faster than any reported income could explain. Even then, suspicion can be wrong. The guide recognises that some parents have legitimately arranged their affairs to minimise tax, and that can itself be a basis for a change, which is a different thing from hiding income. 

Assuming that someone with a low reported income is being dishonest can damage a co-parenting relationship that may need to continue for many years.

What not to do:

  • Don’t confront, snoop or accuse in writing. The other parent receives a copy of Part B of your form and your supporting documents, and anything you tell Services Australia by phone that it uses in its decision. Services Australia says it won’t accept material that is offensive, abusive or derogatory.
  • Don’t obtain evidence illegally. Services Australia won’t accept it. Reading someone’s private messages or accessing their accounts is a poor basis for an application and can create its own legal problems.
  • Don’t use the children as evidence. Services Australia won’t consider statements from children. This includes voice recordings, text messages and social media posts, among others.
  • Don’t leave personal details in what you send. Cover or remove addresses, workplaces, school details and anything else you don’t want shared.

What an application looks like

The steps below come from Services Australia’s own page.

  1. Call the Child Support enquiry line first. They will tell you whether this is the right process and whether you need the form.
  2. Complete the Application to change your assessment: Special Circumstances form and send it with evidence for at least one of the ten reasons.
  3. The other parent gets a copy of Part B and your supporting documents. They can respond, comment on your reasons and apply for different changes of their own. Services Australia will phone both of you to talk it through.
  4. You receive a notice of decision: no change, the change you asked for, or a different change.
  5. A decision can be reviewed. The Act allows for objections, and an appeal to the Administrative Review Tribunal can follow.

     

Three practical points that tend to catch people out:

  • The payments don’t stop while an application is pending. Under section 98V, a pending application doesn’t affect the existing assessment in the meantime, subject to the stay-order provisions of the Registration and Collection Act.
  • Backdating is limited. The Registrar can generally only backdate changes to a child support assessment by up to 18 months from the date of the application. Changes going back further require permission from a court (sections 98S and 112).
  • Services Australia doesn’t publish a decision timeframe on its special circumstances page. Ask on the enquiry line when you call.

And if the issue is simply that your own income has dropped, Reason 8 is rarely the first tool. If your income has fallen by 15% or more, you may be able to lodge an income estimate instead. If it has fallen by less, Services Australia says that on its own isn’t enough to change the assessment.

Also read: What age can a child choose which parent to live with?

Four myths that frequently come up

‘Private school fees will be covered under Reason 8.’ They sit under a different reason. Reason 3 looks at whether the costs of raising the child are significantly affected because the child is being educated the way both parents intended. Services Australia points to evidence such as enrolment forms signed by both parents.

‘My ex’s new partner earns a lot, so that should count.’ By default, it doesn’t. The Act tells the decision-maker to disregard the finances of a person with no duty to maintain the child, unless special circumstances make it appropriate (section 117(7A)(b)(i)). Money flowing between a parent and a partner or relative can still matter, as covered in scenario two.

‘We have 50/50 care, so nobody pays anything.’ Equal care lowers the amount. It doesn’t by itself end child support: the formula compares each parent’s income share with each parent’s care share, so if one parent earns more, a payment can still result.

‘I’m unhappy with the number, so I can apply.’ Being unhappy with the figures isn’t a ground. You need evidence for at least one of the ten reasons.

Before you apply

  • Work out which ground fits. Reason 8 is about money, resources and earning capacity. A different problem may belong under a different reason.
  • Check whether an income estimate does the job if your own income has dropped by 15% or more.
  • Start gathering evidence now. Payslips, tax returns, business records, anything that explains a change in income or shows work was available.
  • Keep it factual. The other parent will read what you send.
  • Know your dates. The 18-month limit on backdating runs from the day you apply.

What you don’t need to have worked out

You don’t need to know which reason fits, what evidence you have or whether you have a case. That is what the first conversation is for.

Kingsford Lawyers acts for separated parents Australia-wide, and we’re available 7 days a week. We can also speak with you in 10+ languages.

Book a free initial consultation. No obligation, no pressure.

Phone: 1300 244 342.

General information only, current as of 18 November 2026. It isn’t legal advice, and every family’s circumstances are different.

x

Jaa tämä artikkeli

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Sähköposti

Viimeisimmät viestit

When your ex stops working or reports no income, child support can stop matching real life. Here is how a Reason 8 change of assessment works, from both sides.

You can be legally divorced and still have no binding property settlement. Here is how divorce and property differ, and the 12-month clock that starts when the order takes effect.

When most people think of “white-collar crime,”  they imagine things like a courtroom drama with a corporate executive, a fraud squad raid …

Miten voimme auttaa?

Jos haluat puhua Kingsfordin asianajajan kanssa tapauksestasi, soita meille osoitteeseen
1300 244 342 for a confidential, obligation-free chat.

WE SPEAK – ENGLISH, ITALIAN, MANDARIN, FINNISH, PORTUGUESE, RUSSIAN, BENGALI, HINDI, URDU, GREEK, AFRIKAANS, SPANISH, ARABIC AND PUNJABI

author avatar
Stefanie Fontana Special Counsel
Stefanie Fontana is a Special Counsel at Kingsford Lawyers with a Master's in Family Law and over 15 years of experience in insolvency law. She is a passionate family law advocate and community contributor who speaks English and Italian.
fiSuomi

VARAA KONSULTAATIO

Aikataulu Ilmainen kuuleminen lakimiehemme ja vastaanottaa $500 luotto nyt

Ota meihin yhteyttä, niin etsitään yhdessä ratkaisu, joka tuo sinulle mielenrauhan ja positiivisen askeleen eteenpäin.

Miten kuulit meistä?

Säännöt ja ehdot pätevät