Personal disputes

Civil Dispute & Defamation Lawyers Gold Coast & Melbourne

A rejected insurance claim, a professional who got it wrong, or something damaging said about you online can be hard to stop thinking about. Get clear guidance on where you stand and your options for resolving it.

A woman reading a letter on her couch
  • Free chat. No obligation.
  • Enquiries 7 days
  • Offices on the Gold Coast and in Melbourne
  • 10+ languages across the team
  • Google rating 4.8 Gold Coast · 4.7 Melbourne

What counts as a personal dispute?

Personal disputes are civil (not criminal) claims that affect you as an individual. Kingsford helps with:

  • insurance claims that have been rejected or underpaid
  • professional negligence by an adviser, broker, agent, lawyer or builder
  • trust disputes between trustees and beneficiaries
  • contract disputes, whether the contract is written, verbal or both
  • defamation, whether you’ve been defamed or accused of it

Time limits: most contract claims, and negligence claims for financial loss or property damage, must be started within 6 years. Defamation claims must be started within 1 year of publication.

What’s happened?

Clear options for a dispute that feels personal.

Start with what’s happened to you.

Insurance claim disputes

Has your claim been rejected because of non-disclosure, an exclusion clause, alleged fraud or a cancelled policy? Get help understanding the insurer’s reasons and your options to challenge them.

  • Reviewing the decision and the policy wording
  • Internal complaints and AFCA
  • Court proceedings if needed
Book a free chat
Professionele nalatigheid

When a professional you relied on falls short of the expected standard, and it costs you money, you may have a claim.

That can include financial advisers, accountants, insurance brokers, mortgage brokers, real estate agents, lawyers, builders and tradespeople.

  • Assessing whether there’s a claim
  • Working out your loss
  • Negotiating or filing a claim
Book a free chat
Laster

A post, review, email or message can damage your reputation fast. Get help working out whether it’s defamation, and what to do first.

If someone says you’ve defamed them, get advice before you reply.

  • Concerns notices and offers to make amends
  • Bringing a defamation claim
  • Defending a claim made against you
Book a free chat

For disputes involving a business, see business disputes of consumer disputes. Other matters are on our litigasie page.

How it works under the law

How do these disputes work?

Each area has its own rules. These are the questions people ask first:

A storm-damaged living room, the homeowner holding a letter from the insurer
01

My insurance claim was rejected. What can I do?

Ask for the reasons in writing, then make a complaint through the insurer’s internal dispute process. The insurer generally has to respond within 30 calendar days.

If you’re unhappy with the outcome, you can usually take it to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), a free, independent service. Court is another option.

The law requires insurers to act with the utmost good faith. For personal insurance such as home, contents or car, the question is usually whether you took reasonable care not to give the insurer wrong information, including an incorrect answer to its questions.

If a failure wasn’t fraudulent, the insurer generally can’t avoid the policy altogether. Its liability is reduced to what it would have been without the failure. Depending on the facts, that may be the full claim, part of it, or nothing.

02

Can I claim against a professional who got it wrong?

Possibly. A claim usually needs three things: the professional owed you a duty of care, they fell short of the expected standard, and these caused you a loss.

In both states, a professional generally isn’t negligent if they acted in a way widely accepted by peers as competent practice at the time. A court can reject a peer opinion it finds irrational (Qld) or unreasonable (Vic).

03

What is a trust dispute?

In a trust, a trustee holds and manages property for beneficiaries. Disputes can arise over how the trustee manages or distributes the property, who should be trustee, or what the trust deed means. Disputes over a deceased estate are covered on our estate disputes page.

In Queensland, the Trusts Act 2025 replaced the Trusts Act 1973 on 28 April 2026. In Victoria, the main statute is the Trustee Act 1958.

04

What happens in a contract dispute?

A contract can be written, verbal, partly both, or implied from how people dealt with each other. A dispute usually turns on what was agreed, and whether one side failed to perform on time, to the agreed standard, or at all.

Options include negotiation, mediation, arbitration if the contract provides for it, and court.

05

Have I been defamed?

Defamation is publishing something that harms a person’s reputation. Since the 2021 reforms in Queensland and Victoria, the harm to someone’s reputation must be serious.

Before suing, you must give the publisher a written concerns notice. You then generally have to wait until the publisher’s time to make an offer to make amends has passed, usually 28 days.

Truth and honest opinion on a matter of public interest can be defences. A claim must generally be started within 1 year of publication.

Does this sound familiar?

People often get in touch when:

  • An insurer has refused a claim, or offered far less than expected.
  • An adviser, broker or agent’s mistake has cost them money.
  • A trustee won’t explain how trust property is being handled.
  • The other side won’t honour an agreement, even a verbal one.
  • A post, review or message about them is spreading, or they’ve received a concerns notice.

Is a bad online review always defamation?

No. The harm to reputation must be serious, and the publisher may have a defence, such as truth or honest opinion on a matter of public interest.

Act promptly either way: the 1-year time limit runs from publication.

Don’t leave it too late

Time limits apply

1 yeardefamation, from publication
6 yearsmost contract claims and claims for financial loss
28 daysusual period for an offer to make amends after a concerns notice
  • Defamation: 1 year from publication. A court can extend it to up to 3 years if it’s just and reasonable to do so. A concerns notice given close to the deadline can extend it slightly.
  • Contract and negligence: generally 6 years from when the cause of action arose, for most contract claims and negligence causing financial loss or property damage. For negligence, that can depend on when the loss was suffered.

Insurance and complaint schemes have their own time limits too. If a deadline is close, or you’re not sure, get advice straight away.

Book a free chat

Meet the litigation team

Real people. In your corner.

Kingsford’s litigation lawyers include Special Counsel Nathan Kershler, a litigator for over a decade, and Senior Lawyer Hassan Azim, whose practice includes civil litigation.

Kingsford lawyers Nathan Kershler and Hassan Azim at the boardroom table in the firm's Gold Coast office
Nathan Kershler, Special Counsel at Kingsford Lawyers
Nathan KershlerSpecial Counsel
Hassan Azim, Senior Lawyer at Kingsford Lawyers
Hassan AzimSenior Prokureur

    10+
    Languages spoken across the Kingsford team

    Explain what’s happening in a language you feel comfortable with. Tell the new-client team your preferred language so they can check availability when they arrange your free chat.

    ons tevrede kliënte

    One step at a time

    You don’t have to have it all worked out.

    Book a free chat
    1. 01

      Tell us what’s happening

      Send an enquiry or call. You don’t need every document to start, but letters, contracts and any deadlines you know about will help.

    2. 02

      Book your free chat

      Our new-client team will contact you, ask a few questions about the dispute and arrange your free chat. There’s no obligation.

    3. 03

      Decide what comes next

      Talk through what happened and your options, and ask about the work involved and fees before you decide anything.

    Offices in Queensland and Victoria

    Where we help

    Queensland

    Gold Coast, Brisbane & Logan

    Get help with disputes under Queensland law, from early negotiation through to court proceedings. Start with a free chat, and arrange to meet at our Gold Coast office if that suits you.

    Gold Coast · Brisbane · Logan · surrounding areas

    Gold Coast office: 2 Currumburra Road, Ashmore QLD 4214

    Victoria

    Melbourne & Victoria

    Get help with disputes under Victorian law, from early negotiation through to court proceedings. Start with a free chat, and arrange to meet at our Melbourne office if that suits you.

    Greater Melbourne · surrounding suburbs

    Melbourne office: 91A Hudsons Rd, Spotswood VIC 3015

    Defamation law is largely uniform across the states, but limitation periods, negligence rules and courts are set by each state. This page covers Queensland and Victoria.

    If the other party or the events are connected with another state, mention it when you get in touch.

    A little more clarity

    Questions before you reach out?

    Not seeing your question here? Start with a free chat.

    How long do I have to sue for defamation?

    Generally 1 year from publication. For online material, that’s usually when it was first uploaded or sent.

    A court can extend the period to up to 3 years if it’s just and reasonable, but don’t rely on that.

    What is a concerns notice?

    A written notice to the publisher that sets out where the material is, the meanings you say are defamatory, and the harm caused.

    You must give one before starting a defamation claim.

    What should I do if I’ve been accused of defamation?

    Don’t delete, repost or reply in anger. Keep a copy of what was published and anything you’ve received.

    Get advice early. An offer to make amends has to be made within a set time, and can later provide a defence.

    Is AFCA free?

    Yes. AFCA is a free, independent service for consumers. Complain to the insurer first. It generally has 30 calendar days to respond.

    If you’re not satisfied, AFCA can consider your complaint. Time limits apply.

    My insurer says I didn’t disclose something. Is my claim over?

    Not necessarily. For home, contents, car and other personal insurance, the question is usually whether you took reasonable care when answering the insurer’s questions.

    Unless a failure was fraudulent, the insurer’s liability is generally reduced to what it would have been without it. That can be the full claim, part of it or nothing, depending on the facts.

    Can I sue my financial adviser or accountant?

    Possibly, if they owed you a duty of care, fell short of the expected standard, and that caused you a financial loss.

    A free chat can help you work out what to gather first.

    Does a verbal agreement count as a contract?

    It can. A contract can be verbal, written, partly both, or implied from conduct. Proving its terms is usually harder, so gather texts, emails, payments and anything else that shows what was agreed.

    How much will it cost?

    It depends on the dispute and how far it goes. Your first step is a free chat, with no obligation.

    Ask about the likely work and fees before you decide to go ahead.

    KONTAK ONS

    Bel ons om met 'n prokureur van Kingsford oor jou saak te praat
    1300 244 342 for a confidential, obligation-free chat.

    WE SPEAK – ENGLISH, ITALIAN, MANDARIN, FINNISH, PORTUGUESE, RUSSIAN, BENGALI, HINDI, URDU, GREEK, AFRIKAANS, SPANISH, ARABIC AND PUNJABI

    General information only, not legal advice. The law and court limits described apply in Queensland and Victoria and can change. Advice depends on your circumstances. Page last reviewed November 2026.

    afAfrikaans

    BOEK KONSULTASIE

    Beplan 'n gratis konsultasie met ons prokureurs en ontvang nou $500 krediet

    Reik uit na ons, en kom ons werk saam aan 'n oplossing wat vir jou gemoedsrus en 'n positiewe stap vorentoe bring.

    Hoe het jy van ons gehoor?

    Bepalings en voorwaardes geld